What Inference Can Be Made From the David Reimer Case Study?

In the David Reimer case study, the most significant inference that can be made is the importance of gender identity and the impact of socialization on one’s psychological well-being. David Reimer was a boy who, due to a medical accident during infancy, had his penis surgically removed and was raised as a girl named Brenda. The case study follows David’s life as he struggled with his assigned gender, ultimately transitioning back to male and adopting the name David.

From this case study, several inferences can be made:

1. Gender identity is deeply ingrained: Despite being raised as a girl, David Reimer consistently exhibited male-typical behaviors and preferences. This suggests that gender identity is not solely determined by upbringing or socialization but has a biological component.

2. Socialization plays a role in gender identity development: Although David was raised as a girl, he experienced significant distress and confusion about his gender identity. This indicates that socialization alone cannot override an individual’s innate sense of their gender identity.

3. The impact of gender dysphoria: David’s struggle with his assigned gender led to a range of psychological issues, including depression, anxiety, and a lack of self-acceptance. This emphasizes the importance of supporting individuals with gender dysphoria and providing access to appropriate medical interventions when necessary.

4. The importance of early intervention and support: David’s experience highlights the potential negative consequences of medical interventions without considering the individual’s gender identity. It is essential to consider the long-term psychological implications before making decisions about gender-related surgeries or treatments, especially in infancy or early childhood.

See also  What Are the Education Requirements for a Criminologist


Q: Can gender identity be changed through socialization?
A: While socialization can influence certain aspects of gender expression, it cannot change an individual’s innate gender identity. Gender identity is believed to be a deeply ingrained sense of being male, female, or another gender, which is typically established by early childhood.

Q: What is gender dysphoria?
A: Gender dysphoria refers to the distress or discomfort experienced by individuals whose gender identity does not align with the sex they were assigned at birth. It is characterized by significant psychological and emotional distress, often requiring support and appropriate medical interventions.

Q: What can we learn from David Reimer’s case study?
A: David Reimer’s case study highlights the importance of considering an individual’s gender identity when making decisions about medical interventions. It also emphasizes the significance of early intervention and support for individuals experiencing gender dysphoria.

Q: Are cases like David Reimer’s common?
A: Cases like David Reimer’s are rare but serve as important reminders of the complexities of gender identity and the potential consequences of mishandled medical interventions. However, it is crucial to note that David’s case is unique and may not fully represent the experiences of all individuals with gender dysphoria.